America, which portrays itself as the biggest champion of freedom of expression, is once again facing serious questions about this claim. **Shirin Saeidi**, an Iranian-American assistant professor of political science and director of the Middle East Studies Program at the University of Arkansas, has been removed from her position due to her recent statements. Saeidi was accused of praising Iran's Supreme Leader, criticizing Israel, and using the university's official letterhead to appeal for the release of an Iranian citizen.
This incident occurred in December 2025, when the university removed her from the directorship of the Middle East Studies Program on Friday. A university spokesperson told the New York Post that Shirin Saeidi remains an assistant professor of political science, but her administrative responsibilities have been stripped. An investigation is ongoing, particularly regarding the misuse of letterhead.
What were Shirin Saeidi's statements that proved so controversial? According to reports, she posted in support of Iran on social media and public platforms, sharply criticized Israel's policies, and even praised Iran's Supreme Leader Ayatollah Khamenei. Additionally, she used the university's letterhead to write an appeal for the release of former Iranian official Hamid Nouri, who was imprisoned in Sweden—a move the institution viewed as misuse of resources.
Those exerting pressure in this case include American politicians and pro-Israel groups. U.S. Ambassador Mike Huckabee launched a sharp attack on Saeidi, saying that a professor making such statements should be sent to Tehran, where she could teach "hate-filled education." Anti-Iran groups like the Alliance Against Islamic Regime of Iran Apologists (AAIRIA) also pressured the university.
This incident is reigniting the debate on academic freedom in America. On one side is the argument for protecting Israeli and American interests; on the other is the question of freedom of expression. Iranian media and human rights advocates are calling it an example of America's hypocritical policy—where speaking in support of Palestine or Iran comes at a high cost, while other views are promoted.
In recent years, several similar cases have emerged where professors criticizing Gaza or Israel have been suspended or dismissed. Is this the real picture of freedom of speech? This question is becoming a major point of reflection on the independence of American universities.
Sajjad Ali Nayani ✍🏼
